OK, the answer is.... JAMES CAAN!

 

JAMES CAAN!  

Thanks ANONYMOUS for posting the answer!  

i feel so stupid!  I was a real fan, yet I didn't recognize him from this picture.  His son Scott is pretty hot too...  

But James Caan made me drool in THE GODFATHER:  

...and from that time on, he always caught my eye.  He was just a rugged, masculine man, may he rest in peace.  

    

                                               JAMES CAAN (1940-2022)   RIP

                                   https://www.reddit.com/r/BeautifulMasculinity/